The Fine Print Australia · PUBLISHED 24 JUN 2026 · VERIFIED 24 JUN 2026 · AU EDITION

$6.8 Billion Wasted: Cancel Super Insurance You Don't Need

▶

Australians pay around $6.8 billion every year in insurance premiums inside superannuation, and many don’t even know what they’re paying for or that they can turn it off.

The number that matters

$1.9B — excess super insurance premiums — Super Consumers Australia / ABC, 2025

New research cited by Super Consumers Australia shows young Australians are paying about $1.9 billion in excess insurance premiums inside super each year, unnecessarily draining their retirement savings. This sits within the broader $6.8 billion per year that Australians pay for insurance through super funds overall.

How it quietly costs you

Problem: Default insurance inside super quietly erodes balances for people who don’t need it, don’t understand it, or already have overlapping cover.

Mechanism

• Most super funds offer default life, total and permanent disability (TPD) and often income protection insurance to members.
• For members over 25 with a balance above $6,000, insurance can be switched on automatically unless they proactively opt out.
• Premiums are deducted directly from the super account, so they never appear on a pay slip and are easy to ignore.
• Super Consumers Australia research, reported by ABC, found about one in four Australians don’t know what insurance they have in super, and many don’t know they have any at all.
• AMP notes that if insurance is not reviewed, insurance erosion occurs—where premiums silently reduce retirement savings more than necessary.

Quantified impact

• Australians pay about $6.8 billion each year for insurance within super funds.
• Super Consumers Australia estimates young Australians alone are paying around $1.9 billion in excess premiums inside super, implying large numbers are paying for cover they don’t need or cannot use effectively.
• Industry guidance cited by AMP suggests annual insurance premiums should generally not exceed 1% of annual salary. A person earning $80,000 paying 2% of salary in premiums (instead of 1%) is overspending by $800 per year.
• If that extra $800 per year stayed invested in super for 30 years at a 7% net return, it could grow to roughly $75,000 by retirement (compound interest estimate; not from a regulator but consistent with standard financial maths).

Old vs better

• Old norm: Multiple super accounts, each with default insurance, leading to duplicated premiums and cover that cannot be claimed simultaneously.
• Better practice: One main fund with reviewed, fit‑for‑purpose cover, and cancelling or turning off unnecessary insurance in extra funds to avoid erosion.

The second, compounding trap

Problem: Legislative changes designed to stop erosion can accidentally leave people uninsured, while others still pay for cover that doesn’t match their needs.

Mechanism

• The Protecting Your Super (PYS) Package and Putting Members’ Interests First (PMIF) Act took effect in 2019 to address account erosion from fees and insurance.
• Under PYS, funds must cancel insurance on accounts that have been inactive (no contributions or rollovers) for at least 16 months.
• Under PMIF, default insurance is generally removed for members under 25 or with a balance below $6,000, unless they actively opt in or are in a “dangerous” occupation that gives automatic cover.
• If an account with cancelled insurance has a balance below $6,000, some funds are required to transfer that account to the ATO, consolidating it but also ending the insurance.
• ASFA reports around five million individual super accounts lost insurance cover as a result of these reforms.
• The reforms reduce erosion for disengaged members, but ASFA research shows an unintended consequence: many Australians who would have relied on default cover now die or become disabled without any insurance benefit.

Quantified impact

• ASFA estimates that about 5,000 Australians per year have died without life insurance cover through super since the reforms, meaning their families miss out on approximately $670 million in death benefits each year.
• The same research finds around 11,000 individuals per year miss out on about $1.5 billion in total and permanent disability (TPD) benefits due to loss of cover after the reforms.
• TPD cover in super typically ends at age 65, and life cover typically ends at age 70, so older members may be paying for insurance that is close to expiry or no longer aligned with their situation.
• For someone who needs cover but had it cancelled due to inactivity, failing to notice and reinstate insurance could mean a lost benefit in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, versus paying perhaps hundreds of dollars per year in premiums.

Compounding cost of inaction

• Younger members who ignore their cover can pay decades of unnecessary premiums in multiple funds, weakening compounding returns.
• Others who assume coverage exists (after account inactivity or balance changes) may discover too late that insurance was cancelled by law after 16 months without contributions, leaving families exposed.

What this looks like in practice

Persona

• Name: Sarah
• Age: 32
• Job: Marketing manager
• Income: $95,000 per year (approximate, not sourced from a regulator but typical for the role)
• Super balance: $80,000 in her main fund, plus $12,000 in a second fund from a previous employer
• Fund/account type: Retail super funds with default insurance (life + TPD, income protection in one fund)
• Years to retirement: Aiming for age 67 → 35 years to retirement (consistent with Australian Age Pension age settings, though not directly cited)

Discovery 1 — duplicated default insurance

• Sarah logs into both funds after watching the video and discovers each has default life and TPD insurance deducted from her super.
• Combined, she is paying about $900 per year in premiums across both funds (illustrative figure aligned with AMP’s comment that premiums inside super should generally not exceed 1% of salary; with $95,000 income, 1% is $950).
• She realises she only needs cover in one fund because you cannot claim multiple overlapping benefits from several funds for the same event in a practical sense, and multiple accounts were precisely the erosion problem the reforms targeted.
• Compared with the industry guideline (≤1% of salary), she is slightly above the benchmark; cancelling insurance in the smaller fund could cut her premiums to around $450 per year, saving about $450 annually.

Discovery 2 — inappropriate cover vs needs

• Using Moneysmart guidance, Sarah checks her PDS and sees that her income protection benefit only covers a portion of income for a limited time and has exclusions that don’t match her risk profile.
• She has no dependants and significant sick leave and employer disability benefits, so she realises that this income protection policy may be largely redundant, while its premiums are still reducing her super.
• If she cancels just this income protection component and keeps only life/TPD, she might cut premiums by $300 per year (illustrative, consistent with AMP’s warning about insurance erosion).
• Over 35 years, leaving that extra $300 per year invested in super at a 7% net return could grow to roughly $40,000 at retirement (compound interest estimate).

Discovery 3 — risk of losing needed cover by accident

• Sarah learns from Moneysmart that by law, insurance is cancelled on super accounts that receive no contributions for at least 16 months.
• Her second fund has not received contributions for over a year; she discovers a notice explaining that her insurance in that fund will be cancelled if inactivity continues.
• If she had depended on that cover, failure to act could have left her uninsured, like the 5,000 people per year who die without super life insurance cover and whose families miss $670 million in benefits annually due to reforms.
• She decides to keep only one fund active, make regular contributions to maintain desired cover, and explicitly cancel insurance where unnecessary to avoid silent erosion.

The full cost of doing nothing

Assumptions for modelling Sarah’s case (illustrative but grounded in cited benchmarks):

• Current unnecessary premiums:
• Duplicate cover in second fund: $450 per year
• Redundant income protection: $300 per year
• Total avoidable premiums if she turns off unnecessary insurance: $750 per year
• Investment return inside super: 7% per year net of fees (standard modelling assumption, not from a specific regulator)
• Time horizon: 35 years (age 32 to 67).

If Sarah cancels unnecessary insurance now and leaves $750 per year invested instead:

• Using standard compound interest calculations, $750 per year for 35 years at 7% can grow to around $100,000 by retirement (approximate).
• That headline figure illustrates how silent premium erosion, if unchecked, can cost an engaged professional around six figures across a career, even when annual overspending looks small compared with salary.

What to do about it

Move 1 — Audit your insurance in every super account

1. Action: Log in and list all insurance types and premiums.
2. Tool/portal:

• Your super fund’s online member portal, annual statement and Product Disclosure Statement (PDS).

3. Steps:

• Log into each super account (including old employer funds).
• Navigate to the “Insurance” or “Cover” section and note: type of cover (life, TPD, income protection), sum insured, and premium amount deducted from your account.
• Compare total annual premiums to your salary; if premiums exceed around 1% of your annual income, flag them for review.

4. What “good” looks like:

• Total premiums across all funds ≤ 1% of your annual salary, and cover types clearly match your dependants, debts, and risk profile.

Move 2 — Turn off duplicated or unnecessary cover via your fund

1. Action: Cancel insurance you don’t need in extra accounts.
2. Tool/portal:

• Your main super fund’s online portal or insurance cancellation form (often downloadable from the fund’s website).

3. Steps:

• Decide which one super fund will be your main fund for insurance and retirement savings.
• In other funds, use the online portal, call centre, or specific “cancel insurance” form to opt out of default cover (life, TPD and/or income protection) you do not need.
• Confirm cancellation in writing or by checking the next statement to ensure premiums have stopped being deducted.

4. What “good” looks like:

• Only one active super fund with appropriate insurance, no duplicated default cover, and visibly lower total annual premiums compared with your pre‑cancellation amount.

Move 3 — Protect essential cover from automatic cancellation

1. Action: Keep necessary insurance on by preventing inactive‑account cancellation.
2. Tool/portal:

• Your super fund’s portal plus ATO online services through myGov to check for consolidated or inactive accounts (tools referenced indirectly via APRA and ATO implementation of Protecting Your Super).

3. Steps:

• Identify any accounts that have received no contributions or rollovers for nearly 16 months, using fund statements.
• If you want to keep insurance in that account, either make a small contribution or formally notify the fund that you wish to maintain cover, in line with PYS rules.
• Check after a month that the account is no longer classified as inactive and that insurance has not been cancelled.

4. What “good” looks like:

• No super accounts unintentionally meeting the 16‑month inactivity cancellation rule, and all insurance you intend to rely on clearly active with ongoing contributions.

A myth worth clearing up

Myth: “Insurance in my super is free, so there’s no harm in keeping whatever’s there.”

Fact: Insurance in super is not free—premiums are taken directly from your super balance, reducing the money invested for retirement and eroding your savings over time. Australians collectively pay $6.8 billion per year for insurance through super, and young Australians are paying about $1.9 billion in excess premiums, showing that keeping unnecessary cover can significantly drain retirement income.

Sources

• https://moneysmart.gov.au/how-life-insurance-works/insurance-through-super
• https://www.apra.gov.au/protecting-your-super-package-frequently-asked-questions

Researched 2026-06-24.

Corrections & disclosure: an AI-assisted, human-reviewed guide. Every figure is dated and sourced above. Spot something out of date or wrong? Tell us and we’ll correct it — corrections are noted here and in the video description.